I am currently taking time out from doing my C&G course to take a class at Quilt University on Fabric Portraits. I’m taking my C&G at DesignMatters. Both are distance learning courses. Both courses are completely online. I never meet my tutor face to face and they never get to see my work in the real.
But there the similarities end. The learning environments are completely different. On my C&G course the course material is available online. It is well illustrated with plenty of photographs. The course itself is well structured with each module building on the ones that went before. There are also galleries presenting the work of students who have completed courses. My contact with my tutor is via email. I send her photos of my work and she replies with feedback. She is my only contact. I sometimes feel that I am working in isolation, although this is no criticism of my tutor. She replies quickly to my emails.
Quilt University is much more like a classroom situation. Each class runs over roughly 2 months and there can be as many as 40 students participating. The class is divided into 4 or 5 lessons, which open online on a weekly basis. The information is good with more text than for my C&G course, but maybe not so many photos, though this is of course a subjective impression. Accompanying each class are a discussion forum and student galleries. In the discussion forum every student can post questions. The tutor replies to them in the forum. At the same time students can send in photos of their work, which are published in the galleries. This format allows you to see what other students are doing, what their problems are, what solutions and tips are provided by the tutor. I find I learn an awful lot from seeing how others approach the same topic from a completely different angle.
I can’t say that one is better than the other. I have certainly learnt a huge amount so far from doing my C&G course. I have had to work far more independently. At the beginning I was a bit frustrated because a lot of the exercises seemed rather simple and at times almost childish, but I realise now that they were laying a foundation for the future. A course has to cater for all levels of ability, so it is not surprising that some things I find easy and others are more challenging. One result has been to open my eyes to the world around me. I see far more detail than I used to. Holiday photos have never been so abstract before
I enjoy the QU classes for the interaction with a group of people. Each class is complete in itself and tends to offer more detailed information on the actual doing. Another benefit of QU is that there are many different tutors, who all have their own style of teaching and work, so that again you see many different ways of approaching the same general topic.
So what’s my conclusion? I guess I shall continue to do both. I have at least another year to go before I’ve finished the work for the C&G Certificate. I am still undecided as to whether I will continue on to do the diploma or whether to maybe aim for a degree at the Open College of Arts or just do my own thing. Meanwhile I shall be keeping on eye on the QU classes and taking the odd course there that takes my fancy.